When a valued employee decides to leave for a new job, employers often scramble to offer a counter offer in a bid to keep them. However, while it may seem like a quick fix to a potential problem, counter offers come with their own set of risks and consequences—both for the employer and the employee.
At Redwolf + Rosch, an Australian recruitment agency dedicated to connecting top talent with leading businesses, we’ve seen firsthand how counter offers play out. In this post, we’ll explore the truth about counter offers: why they happen, whether they’re the right solution, and what both candidates and employers should consider before making or accepting one.
What is a Counter Offer?
A counter offer is a proposal made by an employer to an employee who has already submitted their resignation. Typically, the counter offer involves a raise in salary, a promotion, additional benefits, or promises of career development opportunities. The employer’s goal is to convince the employee to stay, thereby avoiding the disruption and expense of recruiting and training a replacement.
While a counter offer might appear to be a win-win for both parties, the reality can often be more complex. Let’s dive into the key considerations for both employees and employers.
Why Do Employers Make Counter Offers?
Employers typically make counter offers for several reasons, such as:
1. Retaining Experience and Knowledge
One of the main reasons employers issue counter offers is to retain employees with significant experience, expertise, or institutional knowledge. Losing an employee who has been with the company for several years can be costly—not only in terms of recruitment but also in the time it takes for a new hire to get up to speed.
2. Avoiding Recruitment Costs
Recruiting and onboarding a new employee can be expensive. From advertising vacancies to conducting interviews and background checks, the costs quickly add up. In some cases, the expense of offering a counter offer may seem like a more cost-effective option, especially if the employee is highly skilled or integral to the company.
3. Preventing Disruption
If an employee holds a key role within the organisation, their departure could cause disruptions in workflows, client relationships, or team dynamics. By offering a counter offer, employers may seek to mitigate the risk of these disruptions, particularly if a replacement would not be available immediately.
4. Maintaining Morale
In organisations with tight-knit teams, losing a valued team member can have a negative impact on morale. Colleagues may feel uncertain about the stability of the team, leading to decreased productivity or dissatisfaction. By offering a counter offer and retaining the employee, employers can avoid this potential downturn in team morale.
The Risks of Accepting a Counter Offer
For employees, accepting a counter offer may seem like the best way to solve immediate concerns, especially if the new opportunity promised a significant salary increase or career advancement. However, there are several important risks to consider:
1. The Issue of Trust
Once an employee has resigned, the dynamic with their employer can change. Even if the employer makes a generous counter offer, there may be a lingering sense of mistrust. The employer may view the employee’s desire to leave as a sign that they’re not as loyal or invested as before, which could affect future opportunities for growth within the company.
2. Short-Term Solutions, Long-Term Problems
A counter offer may resolve the immediate issue of salary or job dissatisfaction, but it doesn’t always address the root cause of the employee’s desire to leave. Issues such as a lack of career progression, a toxic work culture, or poor work-life balance won’t be solved by a pay rise alone. In many cases, employees who accept counter offers end up leaving within a year anyway because the underlying issues remain unresolved.
3. The Impact on Career Growth
Employees who accept counter offers may find themselves in a difficult position when it comes to their long-term career development. Employers may view the employee’s resignation as a lack of commitment, which could limit future growth opportunities. There is also the potential that the employee may become a “problem child” in the eyes of management, leading to a more difficult work environment in the future.
4. Reputation Damage
If word gets out that an employee has accepted a counter offer after initially resigning, it can affect their professional reputation. Colleagues may see the employee as fickle, or question their level of commitment. This can damage relationships within the workplace, and could make it more difficult for the employee to move up the ladder or find new opportunities in the future.
Why Do Candidates Choose to Accept Counter Offers?
Despite the risks, there are valid reasons why employees might choose to accept a counter offer, including:
1. Financial Incentives
A salary increase or bonus offer can be a powerful motivator. If an employee is underpaid relative to industry standards or feels their contribution isn’t being recognised, a counter offer might feel like the solution to these financial concerns.
2. Lack of Confidence in the New Job
Making the leap to a new job can be daunting, particularly if the employee is unsure about the new employer or role. The familiarity of their current job, along with the emotional investment they have in the organisation, can make staying a more comfortable and secure option.
3. Personal Circumstances
Sometimes, personal factors—such as family commitments or the need for stability—can influence the decision. If the employee is in a situation where a significant change is unwelcome, they may decide that accepting a counter offer is the better choice for their personal life.
Why Employers Should Be Cautious with Counter Offers
Employers should approach counter offers with caution. While it might seem like a quick fix, there are several reasons why offering a counter offer may not be in the organisation’s best interest:
1. The Risk of Setting a Precedent
If an employer frequently makes counter offers, it can set a dangerous precedent. Employees might start resigning more frequently, knowing they can use an outside offer to negotiate a better deal. This can lead to a cycle of dissatisfaction and disruption, which is ultimately costly for the organisation.
2. Employee Morale and Team Dynamics
Other employees may start to feel undervalued if they see that an employee who has already decided to leave is being rewarded with a pay rise or additional perks. This can breed resentment and negatively affect morale within the team.
3. Short-Term Fix vs. Long-Term Solution
If the underlying reasons for an employee’s resignation are not addressed, a counter offer is only a temporary solution. Unless the employer makes significant changes—such as improving workplace culture, offering new career development opportunities, or addressing workload issues—the employee will likely remain dissatisfied and may leave again in the near future.
What Should Employers Do Instead of Offering a Counter Offer?
Rather than relying on counter offers as a last-ditch effort to retain talent, employers should focus on creating a positive work environment that reduces the need for counter offers in the first place. Here are a few strategies:
1. Focus on Employee Engagement
Engaged employees are more likely to stay with a company long-term. Employers should actively seek feedback from employees, offer opportunities for professional development, and ensure that employees feel valued and recognised for their contributions.
2. Provide Competitive Compensation Packages
While salary is not the only factor in employee satisfaction, offering competitive pay and benefits is crucial. Regular salary reviews and transparent compensation structures can help avoid situations where employees feel underpaid or undervalued.
3. Foster Career Development
Investing in career growth is essential for retaining top talent. Offering clear career progression paths, mentorship opportunities, and access to training can help employees feel motivated and engaged in their work.
Conclusion: The Final Word on Counter Offers
At Redwolf + Rosch, we understand that recruitment isn’t just about finding the right candidate—it’s about fostering lasting relationships between employers and employees. While counter offers may seem like an effective way to retain talent in the short term, they often fail to address the root causes of an employee’s dissatisfaction. For employers, the key to retention lies in creating a supportive, engaging work environment that encourages growth and development.
For candidates, while a counter offer might provide temporary relief, it’s important to carefully consider whether staying in a role that initially prompted you to seek a new opportunity is the right choice for your long-term career. When in doubt, speak to a recruitment professional who can help guide you through your options.
Understanding the full implications of counter offers is vital for making informed decisions—whether you’re an employer looking to retain top talent or an employee considering your next career move.
Redwolf + Rosch – we are one of the best Employment Agencies in Melbourne, Australia. Call us today or CLICK this LINK to look at our current opportunities.
Connect with us and stay updated with the job market, follow REDWOLF + ROSCH on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
Contact us via email office@redwolfrosch.com.au or call us at 1300 544 652.
Recent Comments